AWS Certified Security - Specialty Practice Questions

AWS Certified Security - Specialty (SCS-C03) exam preparation

AWS Certified Security - Specialty practice questions in English: 180 questions with explanations. The mock exam has 65 questions and 170 minutes.

AWS Certified Security - Specialty free question 9 / 10 · Domain 5: Data Protection

You have three KMS keys with imported key material (symmetric encryption, asymmetric RSA and HMAC). All three were deleted after their waiting periods passed, but you still have the original key material. If you create new KMS keys with the same key material, which of them can be used to decrypt earlier ciphertext or verify signatures and tags?

  1. All three (symmetric, asymmetric and HMAC). The new keys also get the same key IDs as the originals
  2. None of them. Ciphertext from a deleted KMS key can never be handled again, whatever the key type
  3. Only the asymmetric key and the HMAC key. The new keys' key IDs differ from the originals
  4. Only the symmetric encryption key. The new key's key ID differs from the original
Show the answer and explanation

Answer: C

Why this is correct
Once you delete a symmetric encryption key, ciphertext encrypted with that key can never be decrypted. Even with the same key material, you cannot create a new symmetric key that decrypts the original ciphertext. Asymmetric and HMAC keys, on the other hand, can be re-created as new KMS keys with the same cryptographic properties if you have the original key material. However, the new keys have different key identifiers, so you rebuild key policies, aliases, IAM policies and grants for the new keys.

Why the other options are wrong
"Only the symmetric encryption key. The new key's key ID differs from the original" … A symmetric encryption key cannot be re-created even from the same key material. Metadata unique to each key is cryptographically bound to symmetric ciphertext, so a new key cannot decrypt the original ciphertext.
"All three (symmetric, asymmetric and HMAC). The new keys also get the same key IDs as the originals" … Re-creating a symmetric encryption key does not let you handle the original ciphertext. Also, even for a new asymmetric or HMAC key made from the same key material, the key ID differs from the original.
"None of them. Ciphertext from a deleted KMS key can never be handled again, whatever the key type" … Asymmetric and HMAC keys can be re-created as new KMS keys with the same cryptographic properties if you have the original key material. This is because KMS RSA ciphertext and signatures, ECC signatures and HMAC tags are in a standard form that contains no key-specific security mechanism.

Key point
Deleting the KMS key itself cannot be undone, but deleting imported key material is temporary, and you can restore it by importing the same key material again. Ciphertext from a symmetric encryption key cannot be decrypted outside AWS KMS even if the key was made with imported key material.

Go to the AWS Certified Security - Specialty practice app (10 free questions; purchase unlocks all questions)

See the full practice set